My siste and I had...

Liked: Location was ideal and the room was lovely. It had a view of the water. The outside porch was perfect with a fireplace. The coffee was free.
Disliked: The breakfast was prix fixe. It would have been nice to have a la carte choices.

Loved it. Beautiful, cozy lovely.

Disliked: The bright cafeteria lights Amat the restaurant for dinner. One 1 main problem was the restaurant that I won’t eat dinner at again. Cold, sterile feeeling with unimaginative food.

Excellent, would go back again

Exceptional

Beautiful gem in Shelter Island

Liked: Beautiful and charming interior design, beautiful views, very relaxing, comfortable rooms.
Disliked: Over priced, expensive to get to (ferry), at this price point they should include breakfast.

Very good

Exceptional

The Pridwin is a grrat...

Liked: Pretty. Comforting. Great location
Disliked: Nothing

Exceptional

Liked: Beautifully decorated (gorgeous!), excellent location (waterfront), a lot of attention to detail, nice amenities (pool, kayaks, bikes, ping pong, tennis).
Disliked: Everything was great!