The Pfister Hotel Guest Reviews
Write a review
Write a review
Sue H, McFarland
Overall, great stay. Only issue was upon check out. I had paid for the room in advance, yet received a bill for $250. It was my name and room, but nothing else matched. The front desk was not helpful and almost rude. It was their mistake and they cleared it up. Not a single, "I'm sorry". The word, sorry, goes a long way with me. Check your bill on the way out!
Liked: Everything else was great.
Disliked: Bad taste left with the final billing process.
Lynn, Hortonville
Liked: Excellent staff, excellent location for Summerfest.
Disliked: Having to pay for Internet from the room.
Sarah Tue, 10 June 2025
Luxurious!
Liked: The cleanliness, the gorgeous lobby and bar, and the art collection. Lovely staff too!
Disliked: I wish fancy hotels in the US used classical furniture rather than corporate looking cabinets and tables.
Jacdau Sat, 7 June 2025
Exceptional
Liked: Lounge near the fireplace, high tea, great location, great food.
Jody Wed, 4 June 2025
Exceptional
Liked: The Lobby as you enrered was Soo Beautiful to see and the offer of a glass of champagne as you arrive was a Wow experience to start.
Disliked: nothing
Alistair Tue, 3 June 2025
Gracious living at it’s best...
Liked: The interior spaces, the facilities and all the up to date mod cons
Disliked: Couldn’t stay longer
Amy Tue, 3 June 2025
Beautiful historic hotel with all...
Liked: We had some check in issues where the booking system had apparently went down causing some overbooking. They upgraded the rooms, one only had a pull out couch and not a real bed so they moved that room the next day.
Disliked: lack of Coke products and sundries store options.
Clarence Thu, 29 May 2025
Exceptional
Michael Thu, 29 May 2025
Passable
Susan Tue, 27 May 2025
Exceptional
Liked: Excellent service and food. Annie was fantastic.
Alan Fri, 23 May 2025
A really great hotel
Liked: Great public areas
Lea Fri, 23 May 2025
We will return!
Liked: Beautiful and classy hotel in every aspect!
Disliked: Rooms could use updating, however were spacious and comfortable.