I would stay here again...

Liked: Lots of character, great position, helpful staff
Disliked: Very small bedroom, windows hadn’t been cleaned on the outside for years, bathroom so tight that the shelf above the sink meant you couldn’t get your head down to wash your face after shaving.

Poor

Liked: Location
Disliked: Constant sounds of construction where our first room was. Got moved and then noise of old vents. Not nice staff.

Very good

Liked: Good location in the village. Rooms were small like most NewYork City hotels but adequate.
Disliked: Breakfast service was terrible. We waited 45 minutes and no one would wait on us. We had to leave without breakfast due to an appointment time.

Superb

Liked: Ambiance and proximity to so much!
Disliked: Super tiny room for two people, but for only 3 nights it was fine

Superb

Exceptional

Very good

Liked: Great location and loved the decor.
Disliked: Limited space for guests to relax in the lobby area or be outside their rooms.

Great stay in a lovely...

Liked: We enjoyed the sophisticated, vintage ambience and the lobby bar & restaurant.
Disliked: No complaints.

Boutique hotel with a lot...

Liked: Very friendly staff. Great location. A cozy vibe. Excellent coffee and decent breakfast. Charming setting and decor. They are upfront about the tiny size of the room--and that's find. They are well designed. However, the walls are thin. I guess it's NY. Not sure what was happening next door but someone was having a good time.
Disliked: Did not really want to hear the guest next door and their friend.