Small but perfectly formed

Liked: Great location, hotel was full of character and very cosy. Didn't mind that the rooms are quite small as the bar area was so nice to relax in, and they save lots of seats for guests. Rooms were very well appointed, quiet and comfortable.
Disliked: Needed a hook to hang our coats up in the room (not much room in wardrobe and didn't want to put wet things in with dry clothes), otherwise impressed by what they accomplished in a space so small!

Exceptional

Fabulous

Liked: Bar restaurant and beds
Disliked: Rooms are small

Charming, stylish and clean

Liked: Breakfast and the downstairs lobby were fantastic. Building is stylish and modern without feeling overly trendy. Everything was spic and span. The location, near Washington Square Park, was perfect for sightseeing and walking in a charming part of Manhattan.
Disliked: We found the mattress a little too firm, and the shower leaked on the bathroom floor.

Exceptional

Liked: Ideal location. Very clean.

Exceptional

Superb

Liked: Great staff. Nice restaurant. Comfy pleasant hotel.
Disliked: Small but typical NYC room.

Exceptional

Liked: Could not be more charming!
Disliked: The rooms are tiny which works for a couple but would not work for friends who wouldn?t want to share a bed and small space

Exceptional

Liked: The room was clean and comfortable. The staff was helpful and professional. I make reservations to stay at the Marlton the next time I came to New York. Thank you, Marlton for a fine experience in New York.