Would stay again

Liked: Tasteful, pretty, good location.
Disliked: Rooms and especially the hallways are small, albeit typical for a hotel of this scale in a historic building. (I got a room one size up from the smallest, but it was still small—only just enough space to do pushups.) Finish is slightly tired, but goes with the style… (Seals around shower door could probably be cleaned better though.) The main stairs have a door half way up that very hilariously overhang the treads of the stairs—surprised this is up to code but whatever! Adds to the charm, or something.

Good

Very good

Comfortable Greenwich village stay

Liked: Location was great for the area we love to visit and walk around. Room was cozy with comfortable bed and we had a nice room tucked in the corner. We enjoyed the lobby area with a fireplace to unwind after a long day. Service was 5. We ate at the restaurant for breakfast and food was fresh.
Disliked: It is stated on the hotel website that the rooms are tiny. Limited pace to put luggage. The closet has the mini bar so it takes 1/2 the space.

Would stay again for sure

Liked: Very charming, Old School, lovely staff, excellent location
Disliked: Bar staff weren't very helpful

Exceptional

will come again

Liked: staff - breakfast - clean
Disliked: small room

Excellent location, limited comfort, mediocre...

Liked: The location is great. The lobby/coffee area is very pleasant and cozy
Disliked: The pastries for breakfast are not the best quality. It should be easy to find better croissants in New York.The room are very small and the cleaning could improve

Very nice stay

Liked: I liked the location of the hotel. Breakfast was good, next time it would be nice to have eggs and ham instead of pastry’s. I loved the fireplace, sitting there was very relaxing and comfortable.
Disliked: .