The Marlton Hotel

Charmin stay in the West...

Liked: The Marlton is charming and historic, with a great location in the West Village. The continental breakfast that’s included is quite delicious, and substantial. The room, while very small, was smartly designed, and the bathroom is a good size with a rain shower. The bed was very comfortable.
Disliked: I think the hotel is showing its age, there were chips in the paint on the walls, cracks in the bathroom tile, and the shower did not drain well (I was in room 409). I also prefer when hotels don’t use the mini toiletry bottles, as they are terrible for the environment.

Great atmosphere in Greenwitch Village....

Liked: Nice boutique hotel and great staff!
Disliked: Smaller rooms

I had a wonderful time....

Liked: Comfortable, clean, stylish, great location, really good restaurant!
Disliked: Always too cold in the lobby and restaurant even on hot days. Terrible pillows, I mean terrible! Other guests smoking.

Superb

Enjoyable stay in a great...

Liked: Great location, the style of the hotel, multiple and fast lifts (as can be an issue in NY), clean, bed was comfortable, majority of employees were very helpful and friendly.
Disliked: No water refill facility in the hotel other than asking the bar. Very small room (but I acknowledge this is pretty standard for NY, and fine for one night stay), we encountered one very rude employee when picking up our room key the evening we checked in, but other than him, everyone else was extremely welcoming and helpful.

Exceptional

Exceptional

Liked: It’s a very nice and stylish hotel room, with old time New York vibes. The amenities are great and they provided everything from toothpaste to slippers. The location is right next to Washington Square Park, convenient transportation to everywhere.

Beautiful room and neighborhood

Liked: We loved everything about the room and the location.
Disliked: The included breakfast is okay, but isn't free since you're still expected to tip (that's obviously okay, but us europeans tend to forget this). However, the prices displayed for the breakfast you get are way too much for what you get. To be honest the whole breakfast situation was a bit confusing.

Superb