Manhattan Club is a nice, reasonably priced hotel in a great location.

Liked: Location. It was within walking distance to the event I was attending.
Disliked: Nothing.

Good

Liked: Bell staff helpful and attentive. Valet parking smoothe in/out.
Disliked: Elevators difficult to get (it was a weekend, but . . . ).

Very good

What a nice home to...

Liked: Since I had a male relative with me, we chose a one bedroom suite and that worked really well to give each of us our privacy. Rooms were spacious and always clean.
Disliked: I really cannot think of one thing that wasn't done to perfection to help guests. Loved it.

we?ll be back

Liked: location
Disliked: only one broken vending machine

semi-decent accommodations but location is...

Liked: location!!!
Disliked: definitely had an issue with the cleanliness of our room!!

Superb

Disliked: the room faced brick walls with absolutely no view. next time I will ask for a room with a bit of a view.

Great location and large rooms!

Liked: Big room, especially for NYC. Amazing to have two bathrooms and mini kitchen.
Disliked: Check in is very late at 4pm. The rooms need an update - at least 20 years old - paint chipping on furniture, etc. Not the cleanest - hairs and dust stuck to the walls

Exceptional

it was special, we reserved...

Liked: Manhattan Club is special. treated like you matter, free to enjoy as if you own the place. asked for special room placement and the two units I booked were side by side. Nice!
Disliked: We liked everything.