The Evelyn Guest Reviews
Write a review
Write a review
Carolyn, Naples, visiting James Beard House Fri, 24 June 2016
The bed was very comfortable, and the bathroom was nice and roomy. Hotel staff was nice; the location is great!
Disliked: No closets! And the noisy renovations to the hotel. Only one elevator working.
Anonymous Fri, 23 May 2025
Good
Liked: Music notes in bathroom design is a nice touch. Downstairs bar/restaurant Location if you need to be around Mid townComfortable beds.
Disliked: I stayed for 4 nights with my mom, and I thought she would like it, but The hotel design is dark, and she didn’t. It’s very stylish, but you can barely see the floor number in the elevator. The room was very small and all grey, so if it’s rainy day it’s super dark. Free breakfast - is drip coffee/juice/tea and a croissant/overnight oats/1 type of yogurt. The breakfast area has kind of 3 tables. So, truthfully saying my mom was not impressed at all and thought that the hotel was cheap… But it was super expensive.
Biljana Fri, 23 May 2025
Superb
Maryanne Wed, 21 May 2025
Exceptional
Jordan Tue, 20 May 2025
Exceptional
Elena Mon, 19 May 2025
Superb
Liked: Location. Breakfast was nice. Bottle water available upon request.
Matt Sun, 18 May 2025
Evelyn exceeds expectations!
Liked: Lobby area and art deco styling. Our room was great, very comfortable bed. Communal areas all very clean. Decent gym. Reception staff always cheerful and helpful.
Disliked: Resort fee is something we haven't come across before, not sure why it isn't just added in to the room rate for transparency. The grab and go breakfast offer is very limited and no price list in the cafe even if you wanted to buy additional items. We understand that the Tusk bar operates as a separate business but that could have been made clear as there was no priority given to hotel guests and it was very expensive. Wine hour is a nice touch but serving warm Chardonnay is a crime.
Amanda Sat, 17 May 2025
Exceptional
Justin Sat, 17 May 2025
Solid NOMAD option that is...
Liked: Location, staff, comfortable bed, quiet and functional temperature control in the room.
Disliked: Room layout was tight and a bit awkward. Bathroom was very small and not functional. No coffee in the room.
Imelda Thu, 15 May 2025
Exceptional
Ashlea Fri, 9 May 2025
Exceptional
0.4 miles from Prince George Ballroom New York | |
t9 mins walking |
l |
Steve B "Excellent food and top service from Monji and the team gave us good menu advice and made us feel..." Read Full Review |
Read All Reviews | Write a Review | |
Reserve Online | |
©TripAdvisor 2025 |
< 0.1 miles from Prince George Ballroom New York | |
t1 min walking |
l |
DarrinSiegfried "Overall terrific experience! Our first time at 57th St. Sanja, our bartender, got the evening off..." Read Full Review |
Read All Reviews | Write a Review | |
Reserve Online | |
©TripAdvisor 2025 |