The Evelyn Guest Reviews
Write a review
1.7 miles from New York City centre |
Write a review
Carolyn, Naples, visiting James Beard House Fri, 24 June 2016
The bed was very comfortable, and the bathroom was nice and roomy. Hotel staff was nice; the location is great!
Disliked: No closets! And the noisy renovations to the hotel. Only one elevator working.
Marten Fri, 19 April 2024
Very good
Barbara Fri, 19 April 2024
Superb
Giovanni Thu, 18 April 2024
Very good
Francesco Thu, 18 April 2024
Exceptional
Flavio Wed, 17 April 2024
False alarm during the night
Liked: Design and cocktail bar
Disliked: Horrible breakfastRoom too small for a 5star hotelToo expensive for its standard
Kristina Mon, 15 April 2024
Overall great location, clean facilities,...
Liked: The room was clean, all travel things were provided.
Disliked: Rooms are tiny, you literally almost step into the bed after opening the door, mattress was a nightmare, super uncomfortable.
Caroline Sun, 14 April 2024
Lovely NY stay, made better...
Liked: The room was cute and the hotel was lovely. The bar is modern with a great bartender/bar manager. He is creative and his drinks don’t disappoint. The breakfast at the hotel bakery was the best part of the stay. So delicious and it’s lovely that that is included one meal item and one drink of choice and made fresh on the spot. Transit is within mins walk from the hotel and there are the loveliest doorman there to greet you and open the door. Kyani was at reception and she goes above and beyond to learn her guests and offer suggestions, help and complimentary bottles of water. Lovely work desk and my room was changed to a lesser tiny space and viewed a laneway as opposed to my initial dark room which faced concrete walls. I appreciated the security features too of key card access to rooms. Quaint and lovely room and a comfortable bed.
Disliked: The hotel in general has dark hotel hallways and noise (even from phone alarms and street noise can be heard). The hotel needs sound proofing. The shower was very small and narrow to comfortably shower in.
Simon Sat, 13 April 2024
Exceptional
Liked: Perfect location, central and close to subway. Comfortable hotel. Simple but adequate breakfast.
Grzegorz Fri, 12 April 2024
Exceptional
Liked: Location Tasty breakfast (with coupons in a cafe nextdoor)Cozy barSuper friendly staff
Disliked: No coffee machine in a roomLack of shelves in a room (a big closet but only with hangers) and bathroom for utensils
Kai Fri, 12 April 2024
Great stay in Midtown Manhattan
Liked: Great location in a safe part of Manhattan, very close to Madison Square Park. The rooms are clean and comfortable, and relatively quiet. We were impressed with the breakfast! Good breakfast sandwiches and lattes.
Disliked: The room is fairly small, but perfectly serviceable, and no smaller than most NYC hotels.