The Evelyn Guest Reviews
Write a review
Write a review
Carolyn, Naples, visiting James Beard House
The bed was very comfortable, and the bathroom was nice and roomy. Hotel staff was nice; the location is great!
Disliked: No closets! And the noisy renovations to the hotel. Only one elevator working.
Wyder Wed, 25 June 2025
Superb
Sandra Wed, 25 June 2025
Great location and lovely staff
Liked: The location was fabulous and the room was cleaned every day. Staff were great and friendly.
Disliked: Very little wardrobe space
Colleen Mon, 23 June 2025
Overall cute option, but you’re...
Liked: I see what they’re trying to do, it is very boutique and cute, but overall the property lacks
Disliked: The rooms were extremely dark minus the bathroom, and overall for what I paid I felt like I could get a better room just up the street for a better price. I realized I had to come in earlier for work and when this hotel didn’t have rooms available. I stayed up the street and wish I stayed at that other hotel for the whole stay. It was cheaper and my room was way nicer.
Anonymous Mon, 23 June 2025
Pleasant
Liked: Staff very welcoming and friendly Hotel very clean
Disliked: A lot of uncomfortable noises… loud music on my floor and doors slamming all night long
Yvan Mon, 23 June 2025
Very good
Liked: Amazing location and staff
Disliked: The breakfast grabber and go style
Anne Sun, 22 June 2025
Exceptional
Tim Sat, 21 June 2025
Exceptional
Gabrielle Fri, 20 June 2025
Really nice little hotel ina...
Liked: clean, basic, fantastic location, charming art deco bldg
Rudi Thu, 19 June 2025
Disappointing
Catherine Thu, 19 June 2025
Loved my stay at The...
Liked: Great location, super friendly and helpful staff, spotlessly clean and lovely rooms (a little on the small side, but it is NYC!), great bar. The included walking tour with Streetwise was wonderful, highly recommend!