Smart City Hostels by Safestay Edinburgh Guest Reviews
Write a review
Write a review
Norbert Tue, 26 August 2025
Disappointing
Liked: In a city center... But...
Disliked: The hotel is noisy; you enter through a bar where parties go on for hours. The street it's located on is lower than the main pedestrian area. The street stinks. The shower is connected to the toilet. There are no sheets on the beds. The worst A&O I've ever stayed at.
Sharon Tue, 26 August 2025
Good
Liked: Staff was very nice. This was a basic, safe, clean room at a good price.
Disliked: Bathroom light goes out when you're in the shower (movement sensor). Not all outlets worked.
Smith Tue, 26 August 2025
Bad
Wendy Tue, 26 August 2025
Don’t expect to be able...
Liked: The location was good
Disliked: Within the property on the ground floor they have a bar and beer garden. The window of our room as did many other rooms overlooked this area. The noise and smoke from below was overbearing. If you shut your window this didn’t help at all. The room was stuffy with only a fan to help circulation. The fan was so loud it felt like it was completing the bar noise. Don’t expect to get any sleep. If this hostel was reasonably priced you might expect some inconveniences. But we paid more for A&O Edinburgh than any other hotel in all of UK.
Katrina Tue, 26 August 2025
Good
Madeline Tue, 26 August 2025
Good location
Liked: The Location was great it made it very easy to access everything I wanted to see and do.
Pat Tue, 26 August 2025
Comfortable, met nice roommates
Liked: Curtain found bed great
Disliked: Breakfast
Jameshealey94 Mon, 25 August 2025
Exceptional
Lucy Mon, 25 August 2025
Exceptional
Paolo Mon, 25 August 2025
Very good