Pine Hill Arms Hotel

I would stay here again.

Liked: Historical history. Check-in & check-out process was very easy.
Disliked: Upon arrival, bathroom had hair on the floor, in the sink, and in the shower.

A fabulous spot that you'll...

Liked: This is the quirkiest hotel in the Catskills. There's so much to like about this place. The management is really on point, friendly, and responsive.
Disliked: I wish I could've stayed longer!

Good

Passable

Liked: hot water for tee
Disliked: window not open, bathroom without extractor fan. After used toilet smell stay long time.The photos you show are out date. Restaurant is close. No shelf, hook for towel.

The innkeeper needs to be...

Disliked: This is a case of complete mis-representation through photography. The rooms looked nothing like the photographs. This hotel/inn is an old hippie ski house and has not been renovated since those days, The staff was helpful but did not turn on the heat in the reception room and it was very cold outside.

Exceptional

Exceptional

Disappointing

very comfortable

Liked: beautiful old hotel , very clean & peaceful