Name: Pine Hill Arms Hotel
Address: 288 Main Street, Pine Hill, NY
Telephone: (888) 420-1647

Pine Hill Arms Hotel Guest Reviews

Overall Average Score:

Good (3.6 out of 5)

Write a review

Exceptional

Disappointing

very comfortable

Liked: beautiful old hotel , very clean & peaceful

Exceptional

Liked: It's a quaint spot replete with small mountain town charm.

Cozy room, quick access to...

Liked: Park right out front, warm wood stove welcomes you. Sweet sauna scent to the wood in the cozy room was nice. A quiet, quaint, magical stay for a quick overnight.
Disliked: Room a bit dusty

Stay in your car it...

Liked: Location to Spillian and ski mountain
Disliked: No heat / slept in scarves and coats. No hot water! Ice cold. Terrible mattress, uncomfortable and stains. No space. Couldn’t move in bathroom extremely narrow. Bad customer service. No toiletries or amenities besides WiFi.

Very good

Basic but nice enough

Liked: The hotel is in a really old building where nothing is in a straight line. The lounge downstairs is amazing. If you love a bit of history take a visit to this hotel!As others have said you will either love this hotel or hate it. It is very basic. The room was cold when we got in it (they ask you to switch off the heating when you leave) however it soon warmed up. The room was very small and there was no coffee maker in the room.
Disliked: The restaurant with the hotel has closed so you can’t get dinner at the hotel, but there is a lovely Mexican restaurant walking distance.

Passable

Exceptional

Liked: Peter was a joy to have around and was on site the whole time. The Inn is a rustic, old establishment from the 1800s. It retains a lot of beauty and character that goes along well with the quaint mountain village of Pine Hill. We will be staying again.