Penny Williamsburg Guest Reviews
Write a review
Write a review
Michele Thu, 24 April 2025
My favorite place to stay...
Liked: I love the location, friendliness of the staff and how the property is maintained
Disliked: I’ve never had a problem with anything concerning the property
Joanne Thu, 24 April 2025
Happy stay in the city
Liked: The design of the hotel was cool and the rooftop bar had lovely views across the city. Aircon worked well, and you can Chromecast to the TV. The turndown service was very responsive and made our room very clean and tidy each day. The area around the hotel had a good collection of shops and cafes and it didn't take too long to get into town.
Disliked: Although there was a kitchenette, the hotel did not provide any bowls, plates or washing up liquid/ sponges so it's not really suitable to use for cooking or eatingI also don't understand modern hotels obsession with clear doors in the bathroom. As two friends we don't want to see each other using the bathroom or shower so just be mindful if you're the same.The WiFi also logged out quite often and the upstairs restaurant is only open for breakfast on the weekend.
Susan Sun, 20 April 2025
Favourite NY hotel.
Liked: We had a free upgrade to a bigger room which was great. Easy, comfortable living and staff were really helpful.
Disliked: Price of a pastry for breakfast!!
Sean Thu, 17 April 2025
Exceptional
Sonia Tue, 15 April 2025
Exceptional
Laurie Sat, 12 April 2025
Great room!
Liked: Loveeeee the rooftop it’s an incredible viewpoint. Staff in the hotel were lovely and accommodating, the reception area has lots of little items to buy for snacking etc. the room was 10/10 couldn’t fault it and you get a cute striped robe to wear! Thanks so much!
Jill Tue, 8 April 2025
Positive. I will definitely return.
Liked: Very nice and friendly staff. Well designed room in relatively small space but it had all anyone would need.
Matias Tue, 8 April 2025
Very good
Scully Fri, 4 April 2025
Very good
Andrew Wed, 2 April 2025
Beautiful, well-designed property in a...
Liked: Lovely property, exceptionally well-designed room, comfortable (if a tad small, but this is NYC after all). Friendly staff. The pour-over coffee in the room is delicious. Great shower with wonderful water pressure. Excellent stay. Sidenote: Some of the best pizza in NYC is a short walk away.
Disliked: Can't think of much (most comments would be nitpicks). The only thing I found a bit difficult was keeping the room a consistent temperature.