Pegasus International Hotel

The place was fine &...

Liked: The room was fine.
Disliked: I didn't check too closely, but last time I stayed there, they didn't have decaf coffee.

Exceptional

Liked: We loved our room! 211 right outside the pool! The staff was awesome! Location is 100%We will stay there again!
Disliked: The only thing was the shower. Missing tiles on the shower floor. It needs some love. Still overall wonderful!

I loved the place. very...

Liked: it was in a great location. Right on Duval Street. perfect to get to everything
Disliked: The batroom was a little small, but still adequate for my needs.

Good

Liked: The location is fantastic. It is like a boutique hotel and while there aren't many amenities, we appreciated the privacy and quaint-like feel of the hotel.
Disliked: Air conditioner in the room was subpar.

Amazing

Liked: Very nice hotel, with extremely convenient parking (a real plus by Key West standards). It’s located right on Duval Street, with everything within walking distance. The location is truly perfect. The rooftop pool is also beautiful, with sun loungers and a view over Duval Street.
Disliked: Nothing

You’ll want to be in...

Liked: Location is the only saving grace of this property.
Disliked: Dirty rooms. Bugs in the sink. Termites in my parents bed. Dead birds by pool. Staff was not accommodating. Pictures are misleading. Overall terrible stay.

Key West is always fun...

Liked: Location is excellent and the room was clean, very centrally located.
Disliked: They charge me $200.00 for lodging instead of incidentals as previously stated by Front Desk. Currently waiting for refund to my card from the hotel.

Poor go, elsewhere if you...

Liked: Sheets clean. Towels clean. Location to old duval.
Disliked: Facilities are very old check in area needs help. Elevator scary.. black stairs outside worse. No ac in hallways. Owner will not turn them on ir speak with you directly if issue. Bathroom shower floor not clean. Lysol Wipes turned black. Very loud noise on street. Price you pay to be close to action I guess. Staff very rude could not be helpful. Lighting in room poor. Especially by fridge and microwave area.

Surely from a location perspective...

Liked: Right in the heart of Key West on Duvall Street literally the center surrounded by more shops and restaurants than you could ever try. The price is reflective of the convenience. Also, the rooftop is pretty cool lots of places to lounge and a pool.
Disliked: My only complaint is the size of the bathroom. I’m not sure I’ve ever seen one smaller.