Molly Pitcher Inn Guest Reviews
Write a review
Write a review
Rosemary, Severna P, visiting Hackensack Meridian Health Theatre Sun, 6 August 2023
Loved the Molly Pitcher Inn. Loved the town Red Brick.
Liked: Atmosphere. Cleanliness. Great restaurant and bar. Location.
Mark and Jacklyn B, Delta
We had a lovely room. Everything was clean, quiet and the bed was so comfortable. We ate dinner in the restaurant and the food and service were wonderful. The view of the river was beautiful. We were there to see a concert and it was perfect being able to walk to the venue and not have to drive or worry about parking. Thanks for a very enjoyable stay.
Anonymous Fri, 1 August 2025
Exceptional
William Wed, 30 July 2025
Overall pleasant stay in a...
Liked: Location, history, architecture
Disliked: Small rooms that are outdated
Nadine Wed, 30 July 2025
Amazing pool, beautiful views, comfortable...
Liked: Delicious breakfast- a la carte- not included in room price- with beautiful view
Disliked: Rooms are outdated, bathtub took more than an hour to drain, no plugs in bathroom
Anonymous Tue, 29 July 2025
Always satisfied, here I love...
Liked: Good service very good
Disliked: The evening bartender, made a good drink but needed a personality
Douglas Mon, 28 July 2025
Very good
Anonymous Mon, 28 July 2025
Very good
Tracey Mon, 28 July 2025
Very good
Liked: Food excellent, pool very nice.Rooms spacious and clean. Great AC
Disliked: Layout and no easy Access to lower level rooms. Quite a hike to bring bags and luggage. No real bellboys or assistance. Definitely disagree with white glove service.
Anonymous Sun, 27 July 2025
Good
Anonymous Sat, 19 July 2025
Pleasant
Liked: The location is excellent
Disliked: 1) The rooms need modern upgrades. 2) Our room was located next to loud noise of engines. 3) We were locked out of our room before 11 am with our luggage inside. 4) man said he "didn't know what happened" - no apologies.
Katie Sat, 19 July 2025
Lovely staff, beautiful pool…not going...
Liked: The location was great. The pool and pool bar were lovely with a great view of the Navesink River. Every single Molly Pitcher Inn staff member was absolutely beyond lovely - truly kind, friendly, thoughtful, helpful, gracious; an honestly delightful staff.
Disliked: There were dirty socks on the floor in our room that weren’t ours…ick. The room was unexpectedly tiny (like REALLY tiny). The bathroom door didn’t close all the way. The ice/soda vending machine space was filthy. And out of order. The view out our window…was of the aging and unclean roof of the Molly Pitcher - there must be a way to clean up or cover up some of that refuse and rust.