Mayne Island Resort

Very good

Very good

Superb

Very good

Superb

Liked: Loved the location and the friendly staff. Gave our large group access to a large room to visit together in.Bed was comfortable.
Disliked: Could’ve used a coffee maker in our room

Beautiful!

Liked: Receptionist was so lovely and went above and beyond to make our stay amazing! Views were great from the room and very relaxing pool and hot tub
Disliked: Walls were a lil thin so could hear people in the hallways but everything got quiet after 10pm so it didn’t bother us too much

A $400 per nite stay...

Liked: bed was comfortable, heated floor in bathroom was nice.
Disliked: For the price $400/nite, the resort and room failed to meet our expectations. No continental breakfast; barbeque not cleaned and no cleaning tools provided until requested; paper salt and pepper packets; water kettle extremely calcified and not clean; coffee maker extremely dirty and beyond useful life (not enough coffee provided for the 3 nite stay); no robes until requested; unsanitary hottub (extremely foamy); steam room unclean; patio door foggy due to failed seal; broken gas fireplace on/off switch and extremely dirty fireplace window that requires service.

I would still recommend but...

Liked: What was there was great—the view, the people. The staff were exceptionally nice and helpful. Of the two restaurants on the island (that we found), both were pretty good.
Disliked: The room was too sparse. It contained a king bed, two 12-inch shelves, and a fridge—no chairs, no desk, and nowhere to place suitcases. There were four hooks for towels, clothes, and jackets, leaving suitcases on the floor beside the bed. The two tiny 12-inch shelves were already occupied with two wine glasses, a phone, TV remotes, and a tissue box, leaving little space for our own belongings.The room was small, which we expected, as we had chosen their lowest-priced option—still over $200 per night. However, there was nowhere for me to sit and work while letting my wife sleep. I had to work in the car since the lobby only had two Queen Anne chairs, which weren’t practical for using a laptop. The bathroom vanity held a hairdryer and soap, with just enough space for our shared toiletries and makeup.The hallway, though maintaining its original wood floors, was very noisy—it could benefit from a runner to soften footsteps. Additionally, the door had nearly half an inch of play, causing it to rattle whenever another door in the hallway was opened due to pressure changes.

Peaceful and surrounded by nature

Liked: The views are absolutely stunning, and the vibe is just amazing! It's such a beautiful, peaceful, and uplifting place to be! The staff is incredibly friendly and kind. We highly recommend it. :)