Relaxing stay in a good...

Liked: Free car parking for a good standard hotel is hard to come by, so is a definite plus. The staff were very helpful and always said hello in the passing. When we made a request to the front desk it was attended to within minutes, which was also most helpful. Hotel was clean and has a lovely waterfront location. Easy access to good public transport into the centre of Edinburgh. Comfortable bed and pillows.
Disliked: Overall, the room was a little tired. The bathroom extractor fan did not work so we had a sauna experience. Reported the fault but not remedied during the stay. Nothing else of note.

I stayed here for a...

Liked: Room was very comfortable with all facilities. Wi-Fi reception good throughout hotel. Location was perfect, free parking and easy access to Leith, which was bathed in evening sunshine. I had DB&B with both evening meal and breakfast having a good selection which were very tasty
Disliked: There was no issues here

Lovely relaxing break

Liked: Loved our upgrade room was excellent very comfortable

Exceptional

Liked: Great location and very friendly staff.

Nice hotel, good location.

Liked: Good location, great helpful staff. Good and warm. Bar nice. 24 hour gym. Close to tram.
Disliked: Dinner menu limited and expensive. Taps wonky. Shower reluctant to deliver hot water, fixed shower head made it difficult to wash without getting hair wet. Lighting too dim to read, don't want low light all the time. View was a brick wall and scaffolding. Some ventilation fan noise through pipes from other rooms (long after my fan went off). Breakfast nice but fried eggs tended to have set yolks. Gym could have more varied equipment rather than 6 identical running machines. 1cm gap around bathroom window frosting. Decor too understated, particularly corridors. Frosted layer obscured corridor windows - any view would be better. Would be nice if bars could stay open after 11. These are minor points.

Great hotel!

Liked: This is a lovely hotel at a very god price! The hotel is situated in a lovely spot by Leith Water. The rooms are very comfortable, we were lucky enough to be upgraded, so we had a separate sitting room co and bedroom. Very clean .Good breakfast.
Disliked: Nothing.

Very good

Great location

Liked: Location and friendly staff

Very good

Liked: The Malmaison Edinburgh is superbly located in the Leith Docks area. It has a good size car park and it was nice to be upgraded to a big room on checking in.
Disliked: The rather tired, sombre grey/brown decor became a little wearing after a while. The flush on the toilet in our ensuite was so weak it carried nothing away. It was disappointing to find the floor lamp was non-functional which rendered the room very dark (see comment about decor).