Malmaison Edinburgh City

Very good

Superb

Liked: Absolutely fantastic location! Super easy access to the tram from the airport, the tour buses pick up right outside and a great selection of bars / eateries on the doorstep. The staff were really friendly and nothing was too much trouble. Special mention to the barman who looked after us on our last day while we waited for a late evening flight home having checked out at 11.
Disliked: Breakfast bacon was slightly undercooked for our liking and the hash browns were burnt but the breakfast selection was top notch overall. Would recommend the shakshuka and eggs california.

1 night stay in Malmaison

Liked: Excellent location
Disliked: Dark decor - but some people might like that

Not overwhelmed.

Liked: Pillows and beds are so comfortable.
Disliked: My cooked breakfast was poor. Items either over or undercooked. Would rather have a Premier Inn breakfast any day.Lovely hotel, nice decor, but overpriced, in my opinion.

Very good

Great location, and the staff...

Liked: Location was perfect for exploring the city.
Disliked: Nothing

Fantastic Stay Great Location

Liked: From the minute we arrived in reception we were welcomed, staff were all friendly and helpful. Our room was stunning and facility were fantastic. We would highly recommend this hotel and will be back. Location is definitely ++++

Exceptional

Liked: Room was stunning nice high ceilings, comfy bed, clean
Disliked: N/a

Moody Hotel in a great...

Liked: Really central. Near railway and bus station. A few minutes walk from Princess Street and George Street. Near the shopping centre. Good price for this city centre location. Right on St Andrews square. The room was a reasonable size. The shower was lovely. Bar was moody, and the staff were pleasant. Breakfast was plentiful and brought to your table. There were plenty of other options in the buffet breakfast, too. Freshly squeezed juice. Croissants, etc. Coffee machine and tea options. I'd book again for the price location and staff.
Disliked: Moody decor in this hotel suits the Edinburgh winter. But in the summer you want light. However, our room was pleasantly decorated and had great air conditioning. The shower in the bathroom was lovely. The room was on the 2nd floor. You'd think that would have been above the ground level but not in Edinburgh. We were in the servants' quarters, looking up to the pavement on a main road. We closed the curtains as I'm sure people walking past could look in. Made the room even darker. No noise, though, and the bed was really comfortable.