Disgusting! Black in bed and shower. When I told the front desk they apologized but nothing else was done. A discount for the room would've been nice!

Disliked: Black gnats in bed and shower.

We had tickets to the Orpheum presentation of The War Horse. Enjoyed being so close to The Old Market. We shall return!

Liked: Loved the atmosphere, both inside and outside The Magnolia. Love, love seeing people coming and going and had "ownership" of their stay. Breakfast was fantastic! Staff was great!
Disliked: The beds were listed as queen sized but was only double bed. We have queen sized at home so knew this wasn't correct. It's hard to please everyone but the mattress was so soft we kind of "gravitated" to the middle.

Superb

Great hotel in a very...

Liked: The building was beautiful and the room was a great size
Disliked: Nothing

Not good, I want refund.

Disliked: They didn’t let my partner check in because he got there 2 hrs before me. He had the booking email confirmation. The hotel never requested 2nd guest information, even though they contacted me to clarify mine. They didn’t let him leave the bags with them while he waited. They charge SIX DOLLARS per 1 bottle of water in the room. The shower curtain was about 3 inches off the ground. So when I was done with the shower, the whole bathroom was flooded! I was mortified when I opened the curtain. It was such a dangerous situation. We could’ve easily slipped, fallen, gotten concussion or something worse. There’s no way they didn’t know about this problem. There was so much water. We had to call maintenance. A gentleman came, cleaned it up. By that time all our towels were gone. We requested more but didn’t get any. There was no room service. So at that point, we just gave up on showering the second day. Bottom line, it was way overpriced for what we got. I regret not booking a different hotel. I don’t recommend Magnolia. There was mold on shower curtain, stains on the comforter.

The hotel facilitated a nice...

Liked: Breakfast buffet was fine but not exceptional. Wish we could have ordered a la carte.Fascinating architecture, and good, walkable access to the downtown.Friendly airport shuttle service.
Disliked: Our room had a funky old-hotel smell. Overall, the hotel appeared to need some sprucing up.

Exceptional

Liked: Beautiful building and room

Lovely place to stay with...

Liked: Beautiful historic property with new amenities to bring yesterday so close today making your stay warm and welcoming
Disliked: Nothing

Too short! Wish could of...

Liked: It was a classic hotel
Disliked: Nothing

Exceptional

Liked: It was a beautiful, historic place. Full of charm. The room was immaculate and comfortable.
Disliked: Absolutely nothing

Exceptional