Judge's Lodging Guest Reviews
Write a review
Write a review
Andrew Thu, 24 July 2025
Very good
Liked: Location was great, room was very comfortable, i really liked the patio each room had.
Disliked: The waitress's staff were pretty slow, and the receptionist was quite grumpy on our last day, wouldn't hold our luggage in a locked room, just said we can leave it in reception at our own risk.
Anonymous Thu, 24 July 2025
Exceptional
Anonymous Wed, 23 July 2025
Exceptional
Anonymous Wed, 23 July 2025
A good place to stay,...
Liked: The room was fine and clean and everything worked. The location is very good.
Disliked: The main downsides were the packing up of the courtyard bar area at night and the beer deliveries early in the morning - both noisy and reverberating through the building. At breakfast the supplies of milk for tea and coffee were inadequate (one small jug to share between three), and the butter was molten.
Peter Wed, 23 July 2025
Great location, beautiful building but...
Liked: Location and size of rooms were great
Disliked: Room was extremely hot and the windows didn’t open, so was extremely difficult to sleep.I was on the top floor which requires lots of stairs as no lift, would be a challenge for most people
Elizabeth Mon, 21 July 2025
Comfortable and welcoming.
Liked: Central. Comfortable room with openable window.! No air-conditioning but fan provided.Cotton sheets and comfortable bed and pillows.
Disliked: Nothing particularly.
Jane Mon, 21 July 2025
Overall a lovely stay in...
Liked: The room was excellent. Large, clean, comfortable, quiet, great view. Location perfect. The fod in the bar was very good, staff all friendly and helpful.
Disliked: Breakfast organisation. It was odd being directed to a particular table each morning, usually one is free to sit wherever feels comfortable, e.g. on upright chairs, not on 'comfy' sofa, in sun, not in sun etc etc, felt quite random and slightly intimidating - not as if same table each day possibly allocated to rooms, for eg. Cooked food lovely. Due to very small containers the plain yoghurt and milk ran out frequently and had to ask for refilling. Same fruit salad and croissant. The 'traffic light' system noted busy times so there was obvs more chance for things to run out, but equally containers could be doubled up/larger or staff be more aware to keep a closer eye at busier times.
Anonymous Sun, 20 July 2025
The room was perfect for...
Liked: The breakfast was a disappointment, although an order was taken, clearly the food was pre cooked and most of it was dried out and over cooked. The breakfast buffet was nice. The accommodation was lovely and staff were very helpful. Think it was a perfect location but could have been more generous with the tea and coffee in the room.
Disliked: The breakfast food could have been freshly prepared. I dont mind waiting for good quality.
Mark Sat, 19 July 2025
Exceptional
Liked: Lovely place, in the centre of york so dont have to travel for food drinks etc
Disliked: No parking :(
Elizabeth Fri, 18 July 2025
Very good