Menu

Islander Inn

eef - (888) 323-5826
Islander Inn, 225 Erie Street, Put In Bay, OH -(888) 323-5826
(Map)
3.95
HOTEL RATING: 
GOOD
3.95 out of 5 (528 Ratings)
1.3 miles Put-in-Bay Airport
v5 mins driving
BOOK ONLINE OR CALL - (888) 323-5826
Show Prices
Hotel Description
Located in Put-in-Bay and with Perry s Cave reachable within a 15-minute walk, Islander Inn provides a seasonal outdoor swimming pool, non-smoking rooms, free WiFi and a bar. Private parking is available on site. At the hotel, each room includes a desk. Complete with a private bathroom equipped with a shower and free toiletries, guest rooms at Islander Inn have a flat-screen TV and air conditioning, and selected rooms contain a balcony. All rooms will provide guests with a fridge. The accommodation offers a hot tub. Toledo Express Airport is 70 miles away.

Check-in time: 15:00   Check-out time: 11:00
Enter Your Dates
4
4
CHECK IN
 
CHECK OUT
 
7
1 room
7
2 guests
Amenities View More
y
Free Internet
u
Swimming Pool
E
Fitness Center
B
Airport Shuttle
w
Non Smoking
q
Accessible
x
Free Breakfast
j
Free Parking
A
Business Center
r
Pets Allowed
Other Amenities
` Swimming Pool
` Meeting/Banquet Facilities
` Air Conditioning
` Bar
` Elevator
` Coffee shop
` Heating
` Wheelchair accessible
` On-site parking
` outdoor pool
` Poolside bar
` vending machine
` 24-hour security
` Accessible parking
` Designated Smoking Area
` Free Wi-Fi
` Heated pool
` Picnic Area
` Daily Housekeeping
` Happy Hour
` Non-Smoking Rooms Available
` Wine/champagne
` Outdoor furniture
` Fence around pool
` Kids' pool
` Sun loungers or beach chairs
` Smoke alarms
` Fire extinguishers
` Guests can opt-out of daily cleaning service
` Staff follow all safety protocols as directed by local authorities
` First aid kit available
` Linens, towels and laundry washed in accordance with local authority guidelines
` Access to health care professionals
` Electronic room key
` ATM or cash withdraw on site
` CCTV security in common areas
` Daily disinfection
` Facilities for disabled guests available
` Hot tub/Whirlpool
` Luggage storage & lockers
` Non-smoking property
` Accessible toilet
` Parking available (charges may apply)
` Shuttle service (charges may apply)

Islander Inn Guest Reviews

Overall Average Score: 
Good (3.95 out of 5)

Write a review

2.5

Fair - 2.5 out of 5

Jerome Thu, 24 July 2025

Good place if you want...

Liked: The place was clean and well kept. It was a very pretty hotel.
Disliked: We stayed here in July for Jeep Invasion weekend. The place itself is very clean and looks great. When we got to the pool our first day, we were so excited that we went and booked an extra day. That was a mistake. Starting the next day we were no longer allowed to bring any liquids into the pool. Not even a bottle of water. The guy that confronted us was not nice at all. (He may have been the owner) he actually came running at us as we walked into the pool area like we were criminals. The place advertised as a smoke free facility. That is definitely a lie. They allow smoking everywhere including the pool. There were numerous people smoking cigarettes and weed in the pool as well. One guest after finishing his joint, shoved the remaining piece in the crack of the sidewalk. They have a designated smoking area but that doesn’t get used much. Our room was directly behind the DJ. We could not stay in our room it was so loud. Blasting music, door and bathroom mirror vibrating. The charged us $60 to park but when we returned to the place Saturday afternoon, there was no parking spots. They had us park down back in a lawn. There were parties going on in rooms after dark, one door was open and a cloud of weed coming out. There were kids staying there and the DJ was screaming profanity and inappropriate things. They did not come and clean our room after day one. I had to text them to bring me new towels and toilet paper. The next 2 days they dropped off new towels but did no housekeeping. There also was no microwave or coffee pot in the room. You had to go to the front desk to use the community microwave and free coffee bar. If you’re coming for a bachelor party/bachelorette party, you just wanna hang around a pool and get drunk and want to spend eight dollars on a sun cruiser drink. This is the place for you. If you’re there with your family or middle-aged couple, I would look elsewhere.

5

Exceptional - 5.0 out of 5

Alex Tue, 22 July 2025

Exceptional

5

Exceptional - 5.0 out of 5

John Tue, 22 July 2025

Exceptional

5

Exceptional - 5.0 out of 5

Cheri Mon, 21 July 2025

It was great

Liked: Great location! Very clean
Disliked: No phone in room to contact front desk. Long walk to get to and from the pool. Needed towel racks

4

Very Good - 4.0 out of 5

Anonymous Mon, 21 July 2025

Very good

4.5

Wonderful - 4.5 out of 5

Dm Mon, 21 July 2025

Superb

5

Exceptional - 5.0 out of 5

Anonymous Mon, 21 July 2025

An AMAZING stay! 10/10 would...

Liked: Staff was amazing, perfect location.Great vibes!
Disliked: Better air for rooms

3

Pleasant - 3.0 out of 5

Elizabeth Mon, 21 July 2025

Pleasant

2.5

Fair - 2.5 out of 5

Cindy Fri, 18 July 2025

Not a Happy Customer

Liked: Location
Disliked: Pay $20 per night to park your car at the hotel you had reservations for, they allow outside people to come in and use the pool so therefore paying customers get crowded out of being able to use the pool, outsiders take up parking spaces for paying customers for our golf carts yet we get charged to park our car there.

4

Very Good - 4.0 out of 5

Cyny Thu, 17 July 2025

Very good

Disliked: Golf cart was uncomfortable to ride

Write a Review of Islander Inn
Trip Id (Required)
Your Name (Required)
Your City
Your Email Address (Required)
Your overall rating of Islander Inn
What was good?
What was bad?
Your review of Islander Inn
Islander Inn 225 Erie Street, Put In Bay, OH