Islander Inn

It’s a decent clean conveniently...

Liked: It was clean and close to the night time entertainment scene as well as food . Pool and hot tub area were great.
Disliked: No in room coffee maker, no complimentary breakfast. Both are pretty common in every hotel we’ve stayed in. For the price they could at least have grab and go breakfast items. $3.00 for a bottle of water when you can go buy a case at the store less than 5 min walk. We thought rooms needed more bath towels. First hotel we’ve stayed in out of 7+ on the island where our room wasn’t ready by 1pm. It was a Monday so the place wasn’t full. Their policy like every other hotel on the island is ready by 3 pm. They charge a $200 security deposit not mentioned when you prepay that should immediately be credited to your account the day you leave. We’re still waiting.

Exceptional

Liked: Free parking like the other hotels on the island

Exceptional

Very good

Liked: Great location if you enjoy being within walking distance to all the bars/restaurants. Bartenders were friendly.
Disliked: The signage says that they don't allow you to bring any kind of outside cup to the pool area. We found that to be very inconsistent depending on who the security was at the gate. So every time you want a drink of water, you have to wait in line at the bar for a small plastic cup.

Exceptional

great time

Liked: great location and good onsite golf carts
Disliked: pool music is loud during the day

Superb

Good

Liked: Pool area
Disliked: Small things could be added, like hooks in the rooms to hang towels or wet garments. A door stop to hold door open when carrying things in. Additional gate around pool as we had to walk all the way around to to get to and from the room

Superb