Name: Hotel Sutter
Address: 53 Main Street, Sutter Creek, CA
Telephone: (888) 608-6346
Rating: 4.25

A nice getaway

Liked: Our whole floor was very quiet. The room was cute and staff were very friendly. Our dinner in the restaurant downstairs was really tasty and a great value for what we were served. I appreciated that the room had a ceiling fan because the day was 100 degrees, so the A/C and fan kept us cool.
Disliked: The TV wasn’t the best, and the mattress and bed were hard and rickety.

Exceptional

Passable

Beautiful place would stay here...

Liked: Location, historical decor, small humor pieces like elevator sign and Kleenex box
Disliked: First night was rough (we got moved and it was quickly and kindly taken care of) as balcony was LOUD and AC didn’t work.

Superb

Beautiful hotel in the most...

Liked: Beautiful and charming hotel in the most perfect location! Each room is unique with its own special touch. Food and drinks in the hotel restaurant were delicious and we loved the historic/chic ambiance. The town is absolutely adorable, like a hallmark movie with many great shops. We will definitely stay again!!
Disliked: Not a thing

Quite rooms, fun bar, restaurant...

Liked: Great friendly staff
Disliked: Historical

Would definitely stay here again.

Liked: Liked everything about it. F&B; customer service; quiet in middle of small, cute town; clean room; nice shower; coffee in room; msg & chocolate greeting on bed; midweek price.
Disliked: Full bed is advertised, so nothing wrong at all, however a couple would appreciate a queen bed in the small room. Then again, there is probably a queen option for an extra charge.

It was a fun stay...

Liked: One needs to keep in mind that Hotel Sutter is very, very old. Rebuilt in 1867 after the original building burned down. It was a very fun place to stay and the employees were very helpful, going the extra mile for us to make sure we were well taken care of. The room, although small was quite comfortable with the air conditioning very quiet and working well. The hotel upgrades are nice and the newish elevator, although slow is in excellent condition.We were fortunate with parking for the three nights we were there to get parking right in front of the hotel. Two spaces on the street were available there and each night we were able to use one of them.