Hilton Garden Inn Westchester/Dobbs Ferry NY

Good

It was enjoyable

Liked: The room
Disliked: Paying for packing

Excellent! Highly recommend.

Liked: I loved this hotel. I will definitely stay here anytime I come to NY. The room was super clean and spacious, staff was terrific and helped us with early check-in and late check out, and there's lots of restaurants, movies, etc within walking distance.

Nice hotel near Hudson River...

Liked: Good facility, great location -- restaurants, stores and movie theatre next door. Easy walking paths for dogs. Very nice Hudson River towns nearby. Right off small highway that heads south directly into the west side of Manhattan.
Disliked: WARNING: BREAKFAST IS A FLIM-FLAM. Even if you've paid for breakfast with your booking, the waitress will approach you and tell you that you need to pay for it. This has happened to me on several stays. If you have the presence of mind to remember you've already paid for breakfast, you'll be ordered to go to the front desk for a coupon -- while your breakfast grows cold. You'll point out that hotels all over the world (including, hmmm, Hiltons) print out the list of guests who've paid for their breakfasts already, and that this hotel restaurant even has a little rostrum on which to place such a list. But you'll be met with blank stares -- because why fix the system if all involved can gain extra revenues (and tips) by pleading incompetence?

Superb

Good

Very good

Disliked: The hotel entrance is very difficult to find. You have to drive down an unmarked alley, to the second level of a mall parking garage to get to the hotel entrance. Needs much better signage.

Exceptional

nice passing by hotel

Liked: the room was cozy
Disliked: that there were waters in the room but were not included hahah