Harbor View Hotel Guest Reviews
Write a review
1.0 miles from Edgartown centre |
Write a review
Lydia Thu, 16 November 2023
Impeccably lovely, warm & inviting....
Liked: Stunning view and exceptional service.
Disliked: Price was a bit high for off-season.
Valerie Sat, 14 October 2023
Pleasant
Liked: Location, staff
Disliked: Understaffed
Valerie Sat, 14 October 2023
Pleasant
Liked: Location, staff
Disliked: Understaffed
Lisa Tue, 10 October 2023
Mv
Liked: The location is the best.on the water with a beautiful view but also close to the edgartown shops and restaurants
Lisa Tue, 10 October 2023
Mv
Liked: The location is the best.on the water with a beautiful view but also close to the edgartown shops and restaurants
Steven Fri, 6 October 2023
Exceptional
Liked: Never gave 10/10 reviews but this is exceptionally good
Steven Thu, 5 October 2023
Exceptional
Liked: Never gave 10/10 reviews but this is exceptionally good
Stever Mon, 25 September 2023
Perfect
Stever Mon, 25 September 2023
Exceptional
Jeremy Sat, 2 September 2023
Nicest hotel on the island, for a price
Liked: Fabulous location. Nice building a super helpful concierge and staff. The vibe on the veranda, with drinks flowing from the Club Room at the end of the day is lovely. The "heated" pool is nice (if boring). They make it easy to find your way around, and the staff made our stay there very nice. The restaurant is pretty good (OMG the truffle breakfast sandwich), but also has big misses (clumpy pasta? these are the basics, folks...), and is eye-wateringly expensive.
Disliked: Holy cow it's expensive for what you get. Don't get me wrong, it's a lovely place, but you're really paying for the view, the prestige (all the locals will tell you it's the nicest hotel on the island), and the perfect location in MV/Edgartown. For example, our single room at HVH, for the price of a modest beach house rental on LBI, was a bit... junky. The bathroom lock, one of the two device charging stations, and the hallway water dispenser were all broken. And weird things like the hangers were too large so everything in the closet had to sit at an angle; the pitiful shower spray was like a baby's sneeze. The room is pretty spartan and is basically charmless. We get MV is about going out, but for the money, we were expecting at least a few dazzles or charming surprises.