Close to everything in Skaneateles,...

Liked: The location was perfect - less than a mile to Skaneateles/2 minutes. And we could've walked into town, but it was on a hill :) And across the st is the Hill Top Restaurant - had great bfast there. Hope to go to Rosalie's Italian restaurant (across the st) another time. The Room was decorated so nice, loved the Adirondack theme - bears/moose/antlers/woodsy mirrors etc. Bathroom looked new and clean. There was coffee and ice avail 24/7. It was close to road but heard very little road noise. Staff were ALL VERY nice (especially the one that was staying there with her daughter for a special occasion)! It is owned by Mirbeau so their staff handle everything.
Disliked: 2 things: 1 - the room was damp when we got there - sheets and towels felt damp; there was a small dehumidifier on the floor running. (the AC was on, and it was very comfortable otherwise). We left and came back and it was still the same. Towels we used were still damp the next morning. Told them about it when we checked out. 2 - When we returned the next day after being out all day, we expected the towels to be replaced and bed made, but nothing was done. We called the front desk, and they brought new towels to us as housekeeping was gone. Later I read through the whole confirmation notice , and saw that we needed to call them if we wanted housekeeping to come. (Read all the details!) Suggested they remind people of that when they call them to confirm the reservation, and/or put a notice in the room :) (Live and Learn) Minor - The outside of the place is looking a little shabby, needs some new paint minor repair. (Inside is very nice)

Pleasant

a great unique place to...

Liked: the adirondack decor and chairs outside- comfy bed -closeness to lake
Disliked: missed having a coffee maker in room

Superb

Great facility not so great...

Liked: Rustic but comfy!
Disliked: We had a bad experience with the staff that tainted our stay.

Cozy

Liked: Clean and cozy . It?s .8 miles to center of town.
Disliked: We had to drive to Mirbeu hotel to check in. We received a confirmation call a week prior and no one mentioned this. We took all of our luggage out of the car only to have to put it back in.

Exceptional

Finger Lakes Lodge

Liked: Room is cozy and comfortable! Loved the close proximity to town. Staff was very welcoming. Great value.Highly recommend this on your place to stay list when visiting the finger lakes !
Disliked: Loved everything !

Superb

Liked: The wooden decor was novel.
Disliked: No coffee in the room