Great stay in a comfortable...

Liked: The location was perfect for our stay. We were less than a 5 minute drive to Lionshead gondola. The rooms were a little dated but clean and comfortable, and the hotel was quiet. We were very impressed with the ski rental (inside the hotel) which made for easy access and returns. They also offered a discount to hotel guests. The bar was also very nice and kid friendly. The bar restaurant and Indian restaurant both close at 9 pm which is something to think about if you arrive late. The hotel has parking both outside and a garage option. Breakfast is free - pasties and coffee plus around 4 pm they brought out warm cookies.
Disliked: We didn’t find the hotel check-in staff terribly friendly but the staff in the ski rental and bar made up for this by having excellent hospitality skills. I think the restaurant should be open later than 9 pm and at least mention this on the website.

Convenient, reasonably affordable.

Liked: Location was really good. I had a Mountain View which was exceptional.
Disliked: No real control of the HVAC for the room. It was warm a couple of times and had to open the window / which worked okay. The place is very dated in all areas and could use a refresh.

Good

Economic Option Within Vail

Liked: Proximity to multiple ski lifts and town centers, proximity to a bus stop, cheapest option within Vail during New Year's, decent hot tub and sauna, comfortable room, two sinks, free parking, and friendly staff.
Disliked: Subpar value for the cost, outdated design, pungent foul scent in the lounge, and limited breakfast options.

Superb

Liked: Very good facilities, nice hotel, comfortable. Great breakfast
Disliked: All was right

Very good

Liked: Breakfast was not great, but it was what we expected

We were pleased with the...

Liked: Evergreen had free lite breakfast food. Relatively close to the bus stop. Hotel was quiet and had a decent indoor hot tub. Free parking.
Disliked: We understood we had non-cancellable reservations, but due to I-70 road closure due to snow storm we could not get there for 2 of our 4 nights. It would have been nice of them to comp one of the nights since the situation was outside of our control. There were most likely folks stuck there that could not get out so they could have potentially double dipped on the room.

If you must stay, go...

Liked: Convenient location
Disliked: For the price, due to high season, value was vastly outweighed by the overall mediocrity

Exceptional