Name: Elm Tree Motel
Address: 1384 New York 23, Craryville, NY
Telephone: (888) 608-6346

Elm Tree Motel Guest Reviews

Overall Average Score:

Pleasant (3.1 out of 5)

Write a review

Very good

Good

Bad

Excellent country motel - will...

Liked: I got exactly what I expected for a $100 country motel. It was clean and everything was in working order. The desk clerk showed me the room before I checked in and everything was to my satisfaction. I will stay here on my next trip to the area. The price was excellent. It appears some other reviewers expected a luxury hotel experience and this is a country motel experience.

Very good

Spent one night and that...

Liked: Hotel is old and needs a lot of help. Front office was not inviting and smelled bad. Room was clean but dirty ashtrays outside the doors was not pleasant.

Avoid

Liked: Location
Disliked: No hot water and not clean

Not a chain hotel. Not...

Liked: Private setting- no common hallways with a seating area outside the door.
Disliked: Price

Superb

As a solo traveler staying...

Liked: Friendly, accommodating proprietor. Good location for attractions in the middle Hudson Valley. Comfortable room. Room has a fridge and plenty of space.
Disliked: No internet in rooms. Not a huge problem for me because I spent little time in the room, but this would be a big issue for someone traveling for work. Normally in a situation like this I would resort to using a hot spot, but the local Verizon signal is exceptionally weak. Again, not a big problem in my particular circumstances. The proprietor's advice was to sit on a bench near the motel office, where the internet connection works. Fine for an emergency, but far from ideal.