Commack Inn Guest Reviews
Write a review
Write a review
Erik Sat, 23 August 2025
Do not go there it...
Liked: The place was just absolutely disgusting it smelled and there were bugs all over the place. One of the dirtiest hotels that I've ever slept it was just disgusting
Paul Sun, 17 August 2025
Superb
Liked: Else around a lot of restaurants which we was accessible to and to the highway for us to return back home
Disliked: The bathroom seat was broken at night there's a lot of commotion that was going on don't know what it was but it was making it hard for us to really sleep people with I think a fool in the hallway other than that it was a great day a different look for us I want to look forward to return
David Sun, 17 August 2025
Disappointing
Rivera Wed, 13 August 2025
Bad
Milena Sun, 10 August 2025
Never stay there
Liked: Nothing
Disliked: Everything
Lopez Tue, 5 August 2025
Poor
Sylvia Mon, 4 August 2025
A mixed bag, but they...
Liked: While the outside of the Inn looks very dated, the owner is systematically renovating the rooms, so when I got into the room, I was pleasantly surprised that the room was freshly painted, clean and the bathroom was pretty nice.
Disliked: There were some problems. As I was checking out, I ran into the owner of the hotel and I told him that I appreciated what he was doing to renovate but that I had some issues. I was impressed that the owner was even there to check on the place and perhaps check on the renovations.1. I never got hot water for my shower in the morning. 2. The night time lights outside are WAY too bright. Stadium bright!He was very responsive to my complaints. We will see if the lights get turned down so they don't blare right into the rooms at night. The hot water is a basic and he really must address that.
Gregory Sun, 3 August 2025
Superb
Iryna Thu, 17 July 2025
Avoid to stay in that...
Disliked: Worst property I ever had experience to stay. Such a dirty disgusting place and old, with sockets not even able to use. I would never expect it to be that bad. For the price of $200???? It’s not worth $10. I fell to leave the property as soon as possible. Do not trust photos on the website. It’s worthless.
Munn Wed, 16 July 2025
For your next STD stay...
Liked: I can't believe booking.YUCK even lists this property!
Disliked: This hourly motel has not seen an update since the early 70s, if ever. Built in cassette and 8-track player, mirrored walls & ceiling, cigarette burn marks on the linen. The room looked filthy when we arrived. We slept with our clothes on. Unfortunately, all other hotels in the central Long Island area were booked solid, due to a girl's lacrosse tournament. We should've just cancelled our trip!