Colony Inn

Disappointing

Interesting stay next to colonial...

Liked: Place was clean and spacious. It is an old house (1950's ish?), so if you dont mind staying in a place that is very antiquated, it's a decent value. You must check in at The Valley Hotel a few blocks away, which Booking.com does not state, so it can be confusing. We were a little creeped out at first and had to hide a weird doll staring at us down the stairs, but the place grew on us after the first night.
Disliked: Confusing check in. Beds are in need of replacement but linens were new and clean.

Superb

Liked: The Inn was great; it is an older building that has been very well maintained. The rooms are each decorated like a bedroom from the not to distant past. The floor creaks a bit just like my grandmother's house. It was a very quiet and peaceful stay. Close to Palmer but quiet and cozy. Will be staying here again on my next trip to visit the grandkids.

I highly recommend this rental

Liked: I was exceptionally happy with this reservation. I needed a place for our group of four people. I was given an annex house next to the hotel. It was an old house fixed up for the hotel to rent. We weren’t expecting it. We had plenty of room and it was awesome. I have already told friends who live in the area that they should recommend this to anyone coming into Palmer Alaska to visit, definitely look this place up to stay. I wish we would’ve booked it for a couple more nights instead of a couple of the other places we booked.
Disliked: NA

We didn't find (or didn't...

Liked: cozy and comfortable. Great location

Somewhat tired 3BR house, spacious...

Liked: Large 3br home, great location, historic, quiet, very clean
Disliked: It seems like it was decorated in the 1980s to look historic, but is now dated and worn out. Worn out LR furniture and carpet. Amenities were skimpy….3 BR house but only 2 bath towels and no hair dryer.

Nice stay

Liked: We had the 3 bedroom house. Was old but had everything we needed. Location was great.
Disliked: Nothing

Terrific!

Liked: Stayed in the house and it was terrific! Wish we had planned to stay longer.
Disliked: All good.

Exceptional

Liked: Great location, clean, good value for money