Cave Mountain Motel

Excellent views, room Ok, Check-in...

Liked: The views.
Disliked: Check-in was weird. Owner and Family were gathered outside by the door and we felt like we were being scrutinized, very uncomfortable.

Good

Passable

the staff was friendly

Exceptional

Thoroughly enjoyable throwback.

Liked: Beautiful location on edge of Catskills

Over priced and very outdated....

Liked: Convenient for in and out one night stay.
Disliked: The bathroom rug and curtains both in bathroom and bedroom clearly hadn’t been washed in a very long time. Was told all rooms were non smoking which upon check in were marked non smoking but had smell of old cigarette smoke due to smoking area just outside each room. Office area had very strong smell of old cigarette smoke as well as breakfast area, which was connected to the main house office area. Beds were comfortable with clean bed linen. Overall the property was clean with the exception of the constant smell of stale cigarette smoke.

Stay here if you want...

Liked: Everything!
Disliked: N/a

It felt like being back...

Liked: Completely cozy
Disliked: Nothing to not like