Carthage Inn

Pleasant

Liked: Convenient. Safer than it looks. Very friendly staff.
Disliked: Furniture had stains and our door had a little hole in it.

Perfect except for the people...

Liked: Room was clean and didn't smell. Met basic requirements and was cheap, plus free Wi-Fi and there was breakfast that we didn't eat so if not for what happened the morning of checkout all would be fine.
Disliked: The person who checked us in who I believe is indeed the owner failed to do most of her job at check in. She missed telling us nearly all vital information, and forgot to take information which she later had to come get from us. She at least wrote down on a sticky note the wifi password, the phone number to call (despite having no phone in the room), and that if we stayed past checkout it was ten bucks for every hour. We had a very late night and decided we'd check out one hour night. Before it was even checkout housekeeping was knocking on the door telling us to get out. I told her we were aware that we'd have to pay ten bucks extra and just wanted an hour extra of sleep and she threatened that they'd have to call the police, then called the owner. We began getting our stuff out and she informed us the owner told us we were good and they waived the fee but due to the threat we decided to leave anyways. I informed the owner that we didn't appreciate the treatment and she defended her staff, her decision, and used information she failed to tell us to do it. Long story short the owner is seemingly incompetent and allows so id recommend anywhere else but here and if you have to stay here be out an hour before checkout to protect yourself! Maybe the old management was good but the recent new manager needs more time to learn that threatening guests is a bad way to keep repeat customers.

Will stay here again if...

Liked: This is quite the little gem that we found on booking and decided to give it a try. Quiet, comfortable, and the gentleman behind the counter was really nice as well.
Disliked: Bed to high.

Great experience!

Liked: The room was perfect for me as a disabled person. I walk but need certain assists. The room was very clean and did not have the annoying scent of room "fresheners" (which just screams mold and other issues we are trying to disguise!)
Disliked: There were no negatives.

Clean, comfortable and quiet were...

Liked: We needed late check in and that was no problem. Great location, just what and where we needed.
Disliked: This is very minor. Some of the decor was a little dated but the linens and bedding were very clean and probably new. It appears they are updating it.

Exceptional

It was ok in a...

Liked: It was quiet. The sheets appeared clean.
Disliked: Could have cleaned better. There was hair in the bathroom. The caulk was discolored and appeared moldy. Mattress was hard as a rock.

Superb

Bleh

Liked: Location
Disliked: Property was run down and had to get key replaced multiple times, people drinking and smoking weed right outside my room