Carnegie Hotel

Very good

Liked: Location, staff, breakfast, small size, complimentary drinks/snack area, dead quiet (how did you do that?)
Disliked: No Internet TV, small rooms (duh NYC)

Pleasant

Superb

Liked: Room nicely updated, with very nice shower, comfortable bed. Staff was very friendly and helpful.
Disliked: Breakfast was typical of low level motel chains. That aspect could be improved.

Very good

Solid choice for a clean,...

Liked: I had a pleasant stay at the Carnegie Hotel. The room was quite small, but very clean and thoughtfully organized, with a modern and comfortable bathroom. The bed was cozy, and I appreciated the complimentary snacks and coffee available anytime in the lobby. The staff was welcoming and accommodating, which made the stay even more enjoyable. The location is excellent—close to many city attractions.
Disliked: That said, the rooms are definitely on the small side, with no city views, and there’s no rooftop or terrace to enjoy the skyline. The breakfast area is also quite small, which can feel a bit cramped during busy times.

Exceptional

Accessible Comfortable Hotel

Liked: Position near Central Park and many other must see sites in New York.
Disliked: Breakfast room on the small side but adequate for our needs on this particular trip.

Very good

Perfect!

Liked: It was super neat and clean.Close to Central Park and other shopping areas.They offer free cookies, drinks (softcold and hot) Yogurt/crisps etc at their cafe where you can just help yourself(never seen it elsewhere)MOST IMPORTANTLY: their staff. Ah I left my heart there! They were super nice, well mannered, kind and helpful!ESPECIALLY ALEXANDRA! My luggage broken and she said “ I have a basic one downstairs, if it is still there let me give that to you. She brought it and I put all my stuff in that. I never had such experience, though I travel a lot.Alexandra, hotel is so lucky to have you- all the best dear!