Carnegie Hotel Guest Reviews
Write a review
Write a review
Mitzi Tue, 8 July 2025
We would stay at your...
Liked: Your hotel worked well for us. Bonus was the breakfast, snacks and wine in the afternoon.
Disliked: The room was a bit tight, but we worked around that.
Dan Sat, 5 July 2025
Good hotel needs a good...
Liked: Clean, new room
Disliked: Breakfast
Anne Thu, 3 July 2025
Very good
Rajat Thu, 3 July 2025
Exceptional
Moneish Thu, 3 July 2025
Very good
Thi Thu, 3 July 2025
Very good
Bernadette Wed, 2 July 2025
Great hotel and staff.
Liked: The staff was exceptional. They were friendly and accommodating and helped ensure our stay was comfortable. The rooms were very clean. The location is a short block away from the subway and convenient for walking to the theater district.
Rubin Tue, 1 July 2025
The highest compliment; I'll plan...
Liked: Very comfortable bed, incredibly quiet for a hotel room in Manhattan, convenient to Carnegie Hall, generally great location!
Disliked: The coffee wasn't very good from the automatic machine in the lobby, nor was there a coffee maker in the room. My wife and I are addicts.
Healy Tue, 1 July 2025
Great convenient hotel that is...
Liked: Great location and super staff!
Disliked: Nothing, all good, breakfast could have had more options but the coffee was excellent!
Robert Tue, 1 July 2025
This hotel is a great...
Liked: Room decor/facilities fine; Quiet; bed very comfortable; breakfast Way better than standard 'continental'; evening/24-hour snacks nice; staff very friendly/attentive, allowed early check-in; location great.
Disliked: Room size a little smaller than expectation, esp. given price--but manageable; TV controls unintelligible, and staff didn't clarify things well.