Carnegie Hotel Guest Reviews
Write a review
|0.7 miles from New York City centre|
Write a review
Mark Tue, 30 June 2020
Liked: Location is excellent for midtown business/leisure. Staff efficient.
Disliked: Very bare-bones. No glasses in the room, 4 tissues in the dispenser, given COVID would have been nice to have a coffee maker in the room as most places are still closed.
Carol Thu, 25 June 2020
Anonymous Wed, 10 June 2020
J Sun, 15 March 2020
Three Nights at Carnegie Hotel
Liked: Checking in was an efficient process, and our room was clean and well-ventilated. The concierge and janitorial staff were very friendly, accommodating and skillful, adding to our positive experience during our stay.
Disliked: The glass door to the shower inside the bathroom sometimes ends up dripping on the base and leaving small trails of water on the floor; it was a minor indoor infrastructure/usability issue, and was readily resolved.
Rebecca Wed, 11 March 2020
I'll be back and hope...
Liked: King size room facing street was lovely. Bed was comfortable, pillows and shower, lighting in bath was all comfortable. The room and hotel lobby and elevator are super clean. The elevator works fast, its a boutique hotel which is super nice. Great restaurants next door that delivery from 7am to 10pm. Great location, near everything and every metro.
Disliked: Just wish you had two small metal hooks on the wall behind the door to hang our wet, and big winter coats. Maybe install over by the full length mirror if its a fire hazard to be next to exit door. I hung mine on the door latch. The hotel staff are super kind, with lots of little perks that make this place special. I don't like huge hotels with tons of traffic and germs. This place stands out for it cleanliness and for me in NYC that means everything.
Anonymous Tue, 10 March 2020
Excellent and comfortable.
Liked: Excellent staff. Enjoyed the evening wine & cheese very much. Hotel was like a very comfortable B&B. Enjoyed having tea, coffee available all day and night.
Disliked: Breakfast pack up tends to be a bit early. Advertised available to 10 am but pack up started a few times at 9:30. Staff accommodated our requests. Advertise it closes at 9:30 if that is when pack up starts.
Danielle Thu, 5 March 2020
Liked: Amazing location, close to Central Park and Times Square and very close to subway access, yet quiet. Spotless room. Nice pillows and linens, rainfall shower. Friendly staff. Affordable! This was our second stay and we?ll be back!
Nedaa Sun, 1 March 2020
Liked: Good location comfortable bed and nice complementary snack in the evening
Disliked: No microwave facility even in the lobby
Timothy Sun, 1 March 2020
Jane Wed, 26 February 2020