Carnegie Hotel Guest Reviews
Write a review
0.3 miles from New York City centre |
Write a review
Deniz Wed, 27 March 2024
Very good
Amy Mon, 25 March 2024
Superb
Aleksandar Sun, 24 March 2024
Very good
Charlotte Sat, 23 March 2024
Wouldn’t advise it to any...
Liked: The staff were nice
Disliked: The hotel is super tiny.The breakfast wasn’t a real breakfast. I am deadly allergic to dairy, nothing was written on the « food » if we can even call that food. Felt like a dunki donuts food thing. Take into account that the pictures below are being taken with a 0,5 angle which make the place looks big. The rooms now : I could hear the entire street. The widows are super thin. The bed not very comfy and the TV didn’t work properly. We waited 30 minutes to get our luggage up to our room. It is definitely not a 4 stars.
Alberto Wed, 20 March 2024
Superb
Arno Sun, 17 March 2024
Very good
Liked: Affordable, well equipped and nicely located hotel to explore New York City.
Disliked: One nitpick is that the quality of the breakfast is quite barebones. There’s no variation between days (e.g. there’s only one warm option which was cheese and eggs every day) and the bread was clearly not fresh/repurposed from the day before.
Nick Sat, 16 March 2024
Very good
Paul Wed, 13 March 2024
Perfect hotel in perfect location...
Liked: Gorgeous modern room with very comfortable bed. The early evening wine & cheese selections were very good. We didn’t realize this was offered but it was a very nice touch. In addition, the breakfast was perfect - a step above a simple continental!! Very nice coffee machine with many options!
Disliked: Nothing!
Betty Wed, 13 March 2024
Superb
Deborah Mon, 11 March 2024
Superb
Liked: The person that checked us in was very friendly, accommodated me, my husband and elderly mom, by putting her as close as possible to my husband and my room. I felt very welcomed there and would stay again when I am in NYC.
Disliked: The price of my room.