Carmichael

Unsatisfied and underwhelming

Liked: Friendly staff. Good location away from the main parts of the city.
Disliked: The bathroom was quiet dusty and looked like it had only been cleaned where eyes will definitely look, the toilet rocked. and the bath you couldn’t use and also needed a good clean. Our bed room, the lighting in our room at night was not great. And there was dust on most of surfaces. For the money I paid I wasn’t expecting a red carpet but I expected it to be clean and faultless but it felt a bit unloved in areas.

Incredibly comfortable and welcoming. Highly...

Liked: I had a truly wonderful stay, it felt just like home. The place was incredibly comfortable and cozy, and I instantly felt at ease. Caroline and Carmichael were so kind, welcoming, and genuinely caring. Their thoughtful and warm hospitality made my stay extra special. The breakfast was absolutely lovely, especially the delicious scrambled eggs :) Highly recommended!

Very good

Will be staying there again,...

Liked: Large but homely house.Made to feel very welcome by Michael and Caroline. Even gave good advice with parking, as the car park was full. Nice breakfast with lots of choice. Large family style table for breakfast so got chance to chat with other guests. We were all going to same concert. Beds very comfy and large beautifully kept garden. Opened the window, and Got to hear the sound check in Murrayfield , the night before, was so close. Ideal walking distance.
Disliked: No towels, but none stated on booking, I just didn’t read it properly. Easily solved as lots of local shops nearby. Garden gate was difficult for me to lift as has a broken hinge, but hubby managed ok.

Very good

Liked: Great hosts, good location especially for the rugby stadium and a nice walk into the city centre.
Disliked: Hadn’t realised the room I booked whilst having a private bathroom, the bathroom was down the hallway. Perhaps my fault for not checking the room details.

Exceptional

Liked: Everything was perfect! The owners are very helpful and obliging and are genuinely lovely people

A comfortable stay that had...

Liked: Breakfast was alright staff were friendly and welcoming.Bed comfortable pillows were huge and heavy.
Disliked: The price especially for the cosy room was quite extortionate really. A proper mirror in the room would have been useful.

Very nice

Liked: Froendly and helpful. Close to downtown
Disliked: Toilet rocks a bit

Was ideal for a one...

Liked: Room was cozy and not too small. The owners were very friendly and welcoming.
Disliked: TV in the room was quite small and had no cable so did not pick up any channels.Signage for the property could be clearer.