Menu

Carlisle Inn

eef - (888) 323-5826
Carlisle Inn, 1357 Old Route 39, Sugarcreek, OH -(888) 323-5826
(Map)
4.65
HOTEL RATING: 
WONDERFUL
4.65 out of 5 (318 Ratings)
0.2 miles Ohio Star Theater
t3 mins walking
BOOK ONLINE OR CALL - (888) 323-5826
Show Prices
Hotel Description
Featuring an indoor swimming pool with a retractable roof, Carlisle Inn is located in Sugarcreek, Ohio. The property serves complimentary daily breakfast. Guests can find an Amish-style restaurant adjacent to the inn. Each simply furnished room is equipped with air conditioning. All rooms include a flat-screen TV. Select rooms will feature a balcony or patio. Room service is available. Guests at the Sugarcreek Carlisle Inn can enjoy live performances at the on-site theater. There is also a fitness center, a gift store and children's playground. Free WiFi access is available. Dutch Valley Restaurant is located on the property and serves authentic Amish Dishes. The on-site Dutch Valley Market sells local meats, cheeses and foods. Carlisle Inn is 2.1 mi from Alpine Hills Museum and 7.4 mi from Warther Museum.

Check-in time: 15:00   Check-out time: 11:00
Enter Your Dates
4
4
CHECK IN
 
CHECK OUT
 
7
1 room
7
2 guests
Amenities View More
y
Free Internet
j
Free Parking
u
Swimming Pool
E
Fitness Center
A
Business Center
w
Non Smoking
q
Accessible
x
Free Breakfast
B
Airport Shuttle
r
Pets Allowed
Other Amenities
` Business Center
` Free Parking
` Swimming Pool
` Golf Course
` Meeting/Banquet Facilities
` Room Service
` Safety Deposit Box
` Air Conditioning
` 24-Hour Front Desk
` Express Check-In/Check-Out
` Elevator
` Children's playground
` Heating
` Fax/photocopying
` Snack bar
` Evening entertainment
` On-site parking
` indoor pool
` Free Wi-Fi
` Restaurant(s)
` Daily Housekeeping
` Convenience Store
` Non-Smoking Rooms Available
` Board games/puzzles
` Smoke alarms
` Staff follow all safety protocols as directed by local authorities
` Shared stationery such as printed menus, magazines, pens, and paper removed
` Cashless payment available
` Linens, towels and laundry washed in accordance with local authority guidelines
` All plates, cutlery, glasses and other tableware have been sanitized
` balcony/terrace
` ATM or cash withdraw on site
` Daily disinfection
` Facilities for disabled guests available
` Fitness center
` Hot tub/Whirlpool
` Luggage storage & lockers
` Non-smoking property
` Physical/social distancing guidelines
` Protective screen or physical barriers in appropriate areas

Carlisle Inn Guest Reviews

Overall Average Score: 
Wonderful (4.65 out of 5)

Write a review

5

Exceptional - 5.0 out of 5

Felicia Thu, 24 April 2025

Quick trip to see family.

Liked: Everything was clean. Saw staff cleaning everywhere, every day. Fresh cookies available all the time.
Disliked: Nothing

5

Exceptional - 5.0 out of 5

Barrie Sun, 13 April 2025

I stay at Carlisle Inn...

Liked: The inn is conveniently located to a restaurant, bakery, gift shop, theater, and market. They are within a short walk. The free breakfast has many options, including hot items. The attendants keep the breakfast area immaculate and well stocked. In the evening snacks and beverages are set out. We also enjoyed the pool and hot tub.

5

Exceptional - 5.0 out of 5

Alex Mon, 7 April 2025

Exceptional

5

Exceptional - 5.0 out of 5

Jessica Tue, 1 April 2025

Exceptional

5

Exceptional - 5.0 out of 5

Laura Fri, 14 March 2025

Peaceful, relaxing Inn.

Liked: The Inn was absolutely beautiful; it was spotless and extremely well kept. Our bed was in my mind "perfect" and I promise I slept better than I have in a year. I personally LOVED what I thought of as a reading room on the 1st floor with a fireplace. My husband and I utilized this space daily. (I could have stayed in there for hours) ❤️ My favorite customer service employee (I didnt get her name) was a WONDERFUL lady with the cutest little round green framed glasses. If I owned or managed this facility I would be sure she was at that desk 40 hours per week. I am a tenured Retail Manager and she gave me the EXACT experience that I want my customers to have. We had a wonderful stay at this facility.
Disliked: No complaints.

4.5

Wonderful - 4.5 out of 5

Westich Tue, 4 March 2025

Superb

Liked: Breakfast was very good.

4.5

Wonderful - 4.5 out of 5

Pethrona Wed, 11 December 2024

Quick break

Liked: Everything. We had a fantastic room with jacuzzi tub and fireplace.Staff very accommodating Great area. Market and restaurant on site. Coffee and hot chocolate 24/7
Disliked: Breakfast not that great.Would have appreciated no pork meat optionsMore fruit choices

4.5

Wonderful - 4.5 out of 5

Reinzi Thu, 28 November 2024

great stay. We will return...

Liked: the lady taking care of the breakfast (Akaua) was very welcoming to us. She was very nice.

5

Exceptional - 5.0 out of 5

Christine Wed, 30 October 2024

Amazing will be back.

Liked: Carlisle Inn was a fabulous place to stay. Staff was knowledgeable and friendly. Exceptionally clean.

5

Exceptional - 5.0 out of 5

Mason Sun, 27 October 2024

Exceptional

Liked: Very friendly staff and environment. Beautiful scenery.
Disliked: Guest services was unavailable for a lengthy period of time in the late evening.

Write a Review of Carlisle Inn
Trip Id (Required)
Your Name (Required)
Your City
Your Email Address (Required)
Your overall rating of Carlisle Inn
What was good?
What was bad?
Your review of Carlisle Inn
Carlisle Inn 1357 Old Route 39, Sugarcreek, OH