Balmacara Hotel Guest Reviews
Write a review
Write a review
Bilale Sun, 3 August 2025
Terrible and very overpriced. Not...
Liked: Very good location not far from Skye bridge
Disliked: It is not a 4 star hotel. Not at all. The staff was awkward and the atmosphere was eerie. To name a few problems :- No wifi (it works -badly- only from the lobby)- our room was very hot with little aeration, (the window could barely open)- the water was either boiling hot or very cold - the cleaning was done badly (dirts, no shower gels..)- room just above the kitchen (on top of the smells, Indian music played all evening)The price is way too expensive for the service offered. Big regret.
Kenneth Fri, 1 August 2025
Good
Liked: It was a very nice hotel , staff very friendly but struggled to understand customers.
Disliked: It is a beautiful hotel
Eduardo Sat, 26 July 2025
Ok
Liked: Very cozy
Disliked: Restaurant was VERY expensive and food qas not very good
Barry Fri, 18 July 2025
Very good
Dewi Thu, 17 July 2025
Can be better & value...
Liked: Location.
Disliked: expensive for the room/ facilities provided.
David Mon, 7 July 2025
Won’t be coming back.
Liked: Location
Disliked: Unfriendly welcomeVery poor value for moneyNoisy from bar in room. Asked for a room with outside access but was 1st floor. Curtain didn’t work and pulled one completely off the railBreakfast very basic for price. Poor selection. Breakfast only ran until 9. Staff heard saying ‘no more’ even when people still eating. Lights in room were turned off as we were finishing eating. Very rude and obvious. Bumpy mattress. Very uncomfortable. Ridge running right across at shoulder level.
Roland Wed, 2 July 2025
Great location, eat elsewhere
Liked: Location, location and staff
Disliked: Coffee machine didn’t work, dirty towels left in bathroom from previous guest and dinner expensive for quality provided and drinks are Edinburgh prices
Jordan Tue, 1 July 2025
Exceptional
György Mon, 30 June 2025
Exceptional
Dhanashree Sat, 21 June 2025
Stay was ok.
Liked: The view from the room & the size of the room was good.
Disliked: Hygiene wasn’t at its best.The housekeeping staff did not clean the room Nor changed the towels. Used towels were rolled and kept on the bed. Dust bins were not cleaned.