Lovely place …great location …...

Liked: Quaint, simple, clean
Disliked: All fine.

Exceptional

Superb

Liked: Our room was very comfortable. Nate was so wonderful. Gave us recommendations for lunch and dinner and what to do on the island.. The ferry didn't run on our day of departure and Nate assured us it would not be a problem to stay in our room another night. What a relief! Continental breakfast was more than enough with fresh fruit, yogurt, pastry, coffee and tea. House was so convenient to downtown too for walking as we had no car. All in all a great spring adventure during a noreaster!
Disliked: Nothing we didn't like

Nice

Liked: The housekeeper is so lovely. The house is fantastic, the room Cyrus is very cute and very clean, even if the windows are slamed because of the storm outside. The house, an old lady, is genuinely clean and cosyThe breakfast is complete, the house is very well located : 6min walking to the ferry and the less to the restaurants and pubs.

Great location, great value

Exceptional

Liked: One of the best hotels I’ve stayed at, I personally love supporting local businesses and Nate was a phenomenal host very friendly and personable the breakfast setup was perfect light and refreshing definitely recommend to anyone looking for a hotel within walking distance of town!

We’ll be back!

Liked: Charming! Close by but also just far enough away from downtown area. Immaculate!Beautiful continental breakfast. Host and staff were friendly and accommodating.

Exceptional

Liked: We had stayed at Greydon Inn last year. They were booked for the Stroll and knowing how wonderful Nate was from our previous experience, we booked at Anchor Inn.We got the last room in the attic, twin beds which took some getting used to as to not bump our heads on ceiling but lots of laughs!Had a great time all weekend!
Disliked: Twin beds set up under slanted roof line, difficult to get in and out of bed without rolling. Couldnt sit up in bed to read but lovely common area.

Reasonably priced, comfortable room in...

Liked: Very clean, traditional house, great location, warm, comfortable, historic house.