Name: Americas Best Value Inn Carlisle
Address: 1247 Harrisburg Pike, Carlisle, PA
Telephone: (888) 608-6346

Americas Best Value Inn Carlisle Guest Reviews

Overall Average Score:

Okay (2.9 out of 5)

Write a review

Bad

Liked: No breakfast

Other than someone throwing blueberry...

Liked: The room itself was pleasant and the sports emporium next door was a blast. Staff was easy to communicate with and always available.
Disliked: The bottom of the tub was worn, shower curtain stained, and there were weird smudges shaped like a cross on our window and mirror inside. Other tenants staying at the hotel took our blueberry bread we forgot by our car & felt the need to hold onto it until the next day so they could throw it all over the front of my car. The manager on duty said the woman caught on camera is “there all the time”, turns out the local hotel tenants are nowhere near as nice as everyone else in Carlisle, PA.

Bad

Liked: Compfort
Disliked: Stinking

Good

We did NOT stay. There...

Disliked: This place looked so disgusting we turned around (cautiously) and drove out!!! We found another hotel.

Passable

Disappointing

Liked: They have updated the interior, but it remains the old Travel Lodge from 2020 Era. Ugly around the building, and the a/c unit was not powerful enough for the humidity, so it was damp. Dry setting did not help. But it was cheapest in town, rightfully so.
Disliked: See previous.

Did the job but would...

Disliked: Dimly lit room. Faulty light fixtures. No mini fridge. Generally speaking a run-down place.

Exceptional

Liked: Price good deal I'll

Very dirty, very sketchy, and...

Liked: Wasn't one even though it said there was.
Disliked: Very unclean, everything on the bed was stained, some alarm or sprinkler was missing from the room, there was a poop stain on the shower curtains, there was at least one hole in the wall, the bed itself was stained, there were stains even in the drawers from spills that had clearly just been left there, the curtains didn't close right, and the entire building smelled of smoke even when smoking indoors was not allowed.