Very good

A cool hotel in a...

Liked: A cool hotel in a great location. The room, which I shared with a friend, was stylish, spacious, and bright, and I appreciated the attention to detail with regard to amenities (e.g the Nespresso machine and china cups - never to be taken for granted in hotels in the US). The cafe/restaurant was rather good, too. Staff were consistently helpful and lovely. The price was good for D.C. All in all, a very pleasant stay!

Exceptional

Very good

falls short of potential

Liked: The bed and pillows were comfortable. The room was clean. It was centrally located, but not very ideally located.
Disliked: You should be aware that there is a demolished building next door that is being removed and it is quite noisy during the weekday. The music in the lounge/bar area was too loud. Also, although we'd set the room's temperature, it never seemed to get there. It also doesn't feel like it lived up to the marketing. You aren't staying in a converted church; you are staying in the building adjacent to a former church.

Exceptional

A beautiful, clean, upscale, hotel...

Liked: The room was clean, beds were comfortable, plenty of towels, nice mini bar selection with reasonable prices. Nice bar area downstairs with fancy drinks, Nice cafe with baked goods and coffee. Interesting historic building in a great location for Adams Morgan sights yet still within a good distance to get to the monuments and museums.
Disliked: Drinks in the bar are very expensive, and the hotel is not especially geared towards families with kids.

Very good

Superb

Liked: Not close to the Metro. But there are quite a few interesting shops in the area.
Disliked: Not much