Liked: The history.
Disliked: Many steps.

Pleasant

Liked: It's an interesting space.
Disliked: It was older, so sometimes it's hard to tell what is clean or what needs remediation.

Evanston

Liked: Loved the building and its old world charm; gorgeous, huge bathrooms, reading rooms with winged backed chairs, outdoor spaces to sit and enjoy a glass of wine. The hotel is also walking distance to restaurants, cafes, public transit, etc.
Disliked: Noise carries a bit, probably due to age of building and plaster walls, but not terribly.

My stay was comfortable and...

Liked: Yes, the breakfast was very good. All levels of the staff were very helpful and friendly. The room including the bathroom was very clean'. Also, all of the common areas are well kept up and nice to sit in and relax.
Disliked: The phone in the room could not make outside calls. The staff said that it will be fixed soon.

Exceptional

Fun lodging for a change...

Liked: Charming and Historic property, If you are looking for something different from the typical more modern hotel experience you may enjoy this hotel. Very European vibe. Great Breakfast with wonderful pastries.
Disliked: Not a place with much of a view out the windows and rooms were a bit small.

Nice location. Good service. Great...

Liked: Breakfast amazing. Excellent coffee. Comfy and quiet. Interesting decor. Pastries outstanding. Like the high beds. Pleasant staff.
Disliked: Outdoor property needs clean up. Too many stairs. Signage for parking needs to be more obvious and updated. Water pressure was low. Drafty near windows. Plants inside need to either be replaced it cleaned. Not accommodating to handicap people.

Bad

Very good

Exceptional

Liked: Architecture and European feel, beautiful library
Disliked: I don't like music at breakfast, although if mandatory, the 40's music is least objectionable....