The Melville Inn by Innkeeper's Collection Guest Reviews
Write a review
Write a review
Carl Thu, 18 April 2024
Superb
Liked: Friendly Staff, good location for trips to Edinburgh.
Peter Thu, 18 April 2024
Loved it.
Liked: Great location. Easy to find. Staff were great.
Disliked: The stay
Patricia Wed, 17 April 2024
Nice stay here. Is it...
Liked: Great location. Clean and comfortable
Disliked: Was a bit concerned by the fixed windows which meant had there been a fire and we couldn’t evacuate through the room door then we would be trapped.
William Mon, 15 April 2024
Very good
Helena Mon, 15 April 2024
Comfortable & relaxing.
Liked: Good choices at breakfast, good atmosphere in pub and hotel. Friendly, helpful staff.
Disliked: Need better lightning above mirror in bathroom and more comfortable bed pillows. Would have liked to open a window in room.
Alison Mon, 15 April 2024
Very good
Lorna Mon, 15 April 2024
We have stayed many times...
Liked: We were visiting family in Eskbank, soLocation was perfect for us. Also being next door to Dobbies Garden centre was fabulous. Breakfast was amazing and the service excellent.
Disliked: In the rain, it is not perfect to go outside between hotel accommodation and the restaurant.
Angus Mon, 15 April 2024
Could be better
Liked: Location
Disliked: Hard bed dark room
Angela Mon, 15 April 2024
Exceptional
Liked: On arrival ample parking and reception area easily found. Friendly receptionist checked us in and we found elevator easily. Bright, spacious and our rooms (1 Family Room + 1 Double Room) were next door to each other. Room very comfortable and well appointed for tea/coffee making. Our air-con out of order but an oil-filled heated in situ but we didn't need it. No outside noise; Had pre-booked our evening meal at Melville Inn Restaurant located closeby. Good menu choices and drinks selection. Attentive servers on hand. A great overnight trip for our family.
Marnie Mon, 15 April 2024
Pretty good.
Liked: The room was clean and tidy, good amenities, and the pub attached was lovely. The receptionist we spoke to was very nice too. Also close to the no. 3 & 29 bus stop, so very easy to get into the city.
Disliked: The pillows were uncomfortable and lumpy, and one of the spoons was already dirty.